keskiviikko 25. syyskuuta 2013

The meaning and Role of Culture in Learning and Continuous Building of Professional Identity



The definition of digital culture


It has been said that the concept of culture should be approached critically. Even culture based categorization, as any other classification, should be avoided. Everyone is unique. Even though everyone is unique, (s)he bears his or her cultural signature. Race, culture, ethnicity, and religion must be seen as “dimensions along which individuals and samples vary, rather than as categories in which individuals can be classified”. (Phinney, 1996 in Liu, 2007). I agree it´s important to remind that everyone is unique even we all have our cultural backgrounds. It would be too easy to just use stereotypes of different backgrounds, we are much more than just our cultural background. I believe it´s necessary for a teacher to understand different kind of cultures and learner´s backgrounds in order to support learning in an optimal way.

Each student brings their own specific culture to their education. This means that every classroom contains layers of multiculturalism and diversity. It means that educators must think outside their own comfort zone and area of knowledge to develop meaningful learning for all their students. (Harrington, 2010: ICT and the Multicultural Classroom http://www.slideshare.net/jha174/the-multicultural-classroom-and-eportfolios). For an educator it´s important to understand own background. That way own comfort zone and the limits are easier to recognize and it will help to understand different learners too.

 “I think that the first and most important lesson of culture is that it belongs to the people, it belongs to us, it is what we make, and we have tools now more than ever than we did in the past to make culture” (Downes, 2012). To me this is a very important statement. The culture is up to people. This is why culture can change and be different depending on people. This could also explain why one person can belong to different cultures depending on the group (s)he belongs to.




Online culture



Online or Cyber culture is a social place in which human beings interact and communicate and can be assumed to possess an evolving culture or set of cultures (cyber cultures) that may encompass beliefs, practices, attitudes, modes of thought, behaviours, and values (cf. Palaiologou, 2007, 79).



There are some concerns that the lack of face-to-face communication makes intercultural communication difficult and that may result ineffectivity in online education (Hannon & D’Netto, 2007.) This might be true, if online education is done like traditional education. Online education needs careful and different planning and implementation compared to traditional. In many studies it´s referred that online learning culture is something different compared traditional learning. It has been stated that an online culture is “negotiated” rather than “given” (2004, in Rutherford & Kerr, 2008).

This means that online education can be successful if the learners’ communication and knowledge sharing is supported and implemented to be an essential part of online education. Based on my own experience as a learner, I agree that online culture is negotiated assuming that there has been a space for communication and sharing. I have also participated to online courses which have been very traditional, no communication nor knowledge sharing between learners. I believe it´s much more effective learning to let the learners communicate and participate to culture creation. Some values maybe good to give to ensure the wanted direction for culture creation. When I participated inside a company to internal online trainings as an educator or learner, the culture of the company is already there. There is still space for negotiation but maybe less than at school.

If the online learning culture is different compared to traditional learning, how does that affect to whole learning process? It´s easy to assume that the whole learning process is different compared to traditional learning. Learner´s role and teacher´s role is changed. The learning is different. The assessment should be different. The different culture affects to the whole learning environment.

Online teacher


As it has been said, that the traditional, teacher-centered and content-driven learning culture does not produce learning that is needed today. It is crucial to develop learning designs that allow dialogue, reflection and collaboration. That will create a solid starting-point for the group to collaboratively create a multicultural learning culture. (Teräs, Leppisaari, Teräs & Herrington, 2012.) It´s easy to agree to this statement. Working life has also partly changed to this direction.  It seems that for learning, it´s challenging to implement new learning culture to the reality. The change seems to be quite slow anyway compared to working life.



When I was a student, the traditional and teacher-centered learning culture was the way of learning. I have a lot of work experience in modern technology and multicultural working environment, but still I think it´s important to gain also personal experience as a learner in multicultural e-learning environment in order to develop myself as an online teacher. Then also the learner´s way of working will be more familiar and easier to understand. That experience I can then utilize when developing my own way of working as an online teacher.

5 kommenttia:

  1. Hi Tuire,

    Like you I also ”believe it´s necessary for a teacher to understand different kind of cultures and learner´s backgrounds in order to support learning in an optimal way”. I also have work experience in multicultural working environment but unlike you I have close to none work experience in modern technology. This is one of the reasons I am taking this module. Cultures interest me. Teaching is my cup of tea. Modern technology has yet to won me over but I've decided to give it a chance. By combining multiculturalism and e-learning might be the way for me to combine teaching and modern technology.

    This is actually my first real online course I've ever taken, so I'm taking baby steps here. Thus I think it's great that we can indeed communicate and are not learning in ”a traditional no communication nor knowledge sharing” way, because I share your opinion that by communicating and participating in culture creation learning is ”much more effective”.

    You bring up a good point when you talk about your personal experience as an online learner in a multicultural e-environment and using that experience in developing your online teacher identity and online working methods. I think that through this multicultural online learning experience I will gain ingredients not only to my future online teacher identity but also to my face-to-face teacher identity. I think my e-heels have started to get a tad higher.

    -Jonna

    VastaaPoista
  2. Hi Tuire,
    Thank you for your tasks. I understand that you have here combined the aspects of topic task and identity tasks, am I right? I get the impression that you have effectively put together and clarified your understanding concerning the digital culture /online culture. Your reflection supports my understanding that it's maybe more meaningful and reasonable to avoid to compare too much f2f and online working - maybe it''s more fruitful to examine online/digital interaction and communication as a completely different kind of phenomenon. In this module we highlight online / digital culture as negotiated phenomenon (cf. the third area). Your experiences as the trainer of the company seem to support this point of view. Have I interpreted your thoughts correctly? I like that you bring your authentic viewpoint and experience to the discussion.

    Jonna, it's nice to read how you can so easily find common aspects with Tuire in multicultural teaching even though your working environments have been different. I'm interested to follow what do "e-environment and oline working models" bring to your understanding of multicultural teacher identity. Or maybe not any significant change? Let's see in January:)

    Thanks to both of you for reflecting and discussing so actively ,
    Irja

    VastaaPoista
  3. Hi Tuire,
    I have the same feeling as you from company trainings that the culture of the company is already there and in my experience it can be surprisingly strong. Tools, processes, even personal attitudes are often predefined or influenced by the company, leaving less space for negotiation. I'd like to think that in general teacher's and learner's roles in schools are not so much influenced by organisational cultures, these roles are rather "individual thinkers" and perhaps there is more freedom for culture negotiation. Thanks again for your interesting post, I really enjoyed it!
    Laura

    VastaaPoista
    Vastaukset
    1. Laura and Tuire, yours contribution to this learnng culture refletion and discussion from the perspective of companies is very valuable and adds more to think about. Thanks! Irja

      Poista
  4. Hi all,
    thank you for your comments. The more I think about online learning, the more obvious it is that it´s very different compared to f2f. And I would very much like to understand the whole potential of online learning.
    Tuire

    VastaaPoista